How accurate are dog DNA tests? We unleash the truth | CBC News

Date:


If you’re puzzled about the breed of your dog, you aren’t alone. There are a number of dog DNA companies to help owners uncover the mysteries of their mutts.

But a Marketplace test found dog DNA tests geared toward consumers won’t necessarily give owners the answers they’re looking for. 

Marketplace recruited two mixed-breed dogs, one purebred dog and one human (Marketplace‘s very own Travis Dhanraj) to test the accuracy of consumer dog DNA tests. Their DNA was sent to four companies that claim to specialize in dog genetic testing: Wisdom Panel, Embark, Accu-metrics and DNA My Dog. 

Nearly all the results were different, even for the same dog, despite all claiming nearly 100 per cent accuracy rates. 

WATCH | The full Marketplace investigation:

Dog DNA testing kits: How accurate are they?

Curious about what breed your dog is? You’re not alone. Dog DNA testing kits are soaring in popularity. Marketplace recruits several dogs and puts four companies to the test to see which ones are worth the cost and most accurate.

Meet the dogs

Molly, a five-year-old rescue dog from Kuwait, had stumped owner Marilyn Burbidge for years. 

“We think she may be Saluki-Anatolian shepherd, but when you look at her she looks husky, so we have no idea.”

Elinor Karlsson, the director of the Vertebrate Genomics Group at the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, says when a dog appears to be a mix of many breeds, you shouldn’t rely on conventional traits — like looks or behaviour — to determine the breed. 

“People tend to hone in on particular characteristics that they associate with breeds,” said Karlsson, “but once you mix many different breeds together, the traits start interacting with each other.”

A grey and white dog with floppy ears that doesn't resemble any particular breed looks past the camera with deep brown eyes.
Molly is a five-year-old rescue dog from Kuwait. Her adoption papers suggested she is a mix between a Saluki and an Anatolian shepherd, two prevalent breeds in the Middle East. (Michael Cole/CBC)

The second dog tested was Loki, a 75-pound, three- or four-year-old rescue from Istanbul. A former street dog, his owners say he was in a shelter with about 300 other dogs before he was brought to Canada.

“Our guess is some type of terrier-hound mix,” said Jennifer Yip Arnette, who adopted Loki in April 2022. “Our groomer thinks he’s a descendant of the Irish hound, but he’s too small for that breed. So we get asked a lot…. We don’t know.”

A fluffy white dog with floppy ears, one is covered in spots while the other is a solid colour brown.
Loki, a three- or four-year-old rescue from Turkey, has vets, groomers and other dog owners questioning his breed. ‘He has almost human eyes … soulful,’ said owner Jennifer Yip Arnette. (Michael Cole/CBC)

The third dog tested was Quinn, a 16-month-old purebred Great Dane who is also a service dog. 

“Am I 100 per cent sure she’s 100 per cent Great Dane? Yes, absolutely I am,” said Michelle Weger, Quinn’s owner.

A brown great dane dog wearing a vest gazes past the camera.
Quinn, a Great Dane and Michelle Weger’s service dog, comes from a long lineage of dog show winners. (Michael Cole/CBC)

Quinn’s breeder provided lineage documentation for Quinn tracing back to her great-great grandparents. 

A family tree showing images of Quinn's family, along with their names.
According to Quinn’s breeder, her lineage is purebred Great Dane back to at least her great-great grandparents. (Images submitted by Kate Paradis/David Abrahams/CBC)

Quinn is Weger’s service dog for narcolepsy. A well-bred, large purebred dog was important to Weger, who experiences cataplexy, a symptom of narcolepsy where an individual can collapse when experiencing strong emotions. Quinn will sense when a collapse is about to happen, and cue Weger to sit down to avoid hitting her head, typically by grabbing her arm.

Meet the companies

Marketplace ordered DNA tests from four popular companies offering kits to Canadians.

The $150 kit from Wisdom Panel claims to test for over 350 breeds of dogs and analyze over 25 health conditions. Wisdom Panel markets itself as the “world’s most accurate dog DNA test service,” and boasts over 98 per cent accuracy.

Another company also markets its test as the most accurate dog DNA test. The most expensive test, purchased for $288, is from Embark, a Boston-based company and research partner of Cornell University. 

Marketplace also purchased DNA kits from two Canadian companies. A kit from Toronto-based DNA My Dog cost $113 at the time of purchasing in August 2022. At the time, the company claimed to test for around 100 breeds. Now, the company offers different products at different prices, and says it tests for over 350 breeds. Even when advertising under 100 breeds, the company still advertised between 97 and 99 per cent accuracy.

The final and least-expensive test was purchased from Accu-metrics, also known as Viaguard, for $80. CBC previously reported on the company for providing DNA results of Indigenous ancestry for a chihuahua and three non-Indigenous individuals. The company no longer advertises Indigenous ancestry testing, but does advertise paternity testing, drug testing and fingerprinting services.

All companies asked for a variety of information when submitting samples, including the dog’s age, a photograph and in some cases a suspected breed. In most cases, the information was optional to include and Marketplace did not answer.

Due to the questionable results provided by Accu-metrics that CBC previously reported on, Marketplace told the company Quinn, a 52-kilogram Great Dane, was suspected to be a chihuahua, a breed known to be between one and three kilograms. When prompted to enter a suspected breed, Marketplace told Accu-metrics and DNA My Dog that a human sample, provided by Dhanraj, was suspected to be a Central Asian shepherd dog.

The results

In nearly every case, the companies provided different results for each submitted sample.

A graphic showing Molly's DNA results from each company are completely different.
While her owner guessed Molly would be a mix of Anatolian shepherd and Saluki, no companies identified those breeds in her DNA. (David Abrahams/CBC)

DNA My Dog identified Molly’s DNA as having Level 4 bulldog, flat-coated retriever and German shepherd. Level 4, according to the company, represents 10 to 25 per cent of that dog’s DNA, and says the breeds are passed down from grandparents and up to great-great grandparents. 

Accu-metrics also uses a level system, with Level 1 being a higher percentage of DNA — 75 per cent and above, and Level 5 being five per cent DNA or less. The company said Molly’s DNA was identified as containing Level 2 cocker spaniel and Labrador retriever, Level 4 American Staffordshire terrier and Level 5 rottweiler. The company suggests one side of Molly’s lineage is purebred cocker spaniels. 

A chart with one half of Molly's relatives being cocker spaniel, the other half a mix of multiple breeds.
This family tree from Accu-metrics suggests one of Molly’s parents was a purebred cocker spaniel. (Accu-metrics)

Wisdom Panel by far provided the most in-depth breed breakdown on Molly, suggesting it detected 19 breeds in her DNA. The most prevalent breeds were pit bull, chihuahua, German shepherd, Segugio Italiano and xoloitzcuintli, a Mexican dog known for being hairless. 

Embark only identified one breed in Molly: 100 per cent Arabian village dog, a breed not recognized by Canadian, American or European kennel clubs. The company says a village dog is a breed that predates recognized breeds, and whose ancestors are indigenous to a region.

A woman laughing to something behind the camera.
When Molly’s owner Marilyn Burbidge was asked which set of results she found more accurate between DNA My Dog and Accu-metrics, she replied: ‘None of them.’ (Michael Cole/CBC)

“I was hoping for a lot of clarity but I’m more confused now,” said Burbidge upon hearing the results. “What are they doing? What are they testing to get all these different results? Why are they so different if it’s genetic?”

A chart with results from different companies.
No company identified the same breed in Loki’s DNA. (David Abrahams/CBC)

Loki received similar results as Molly, with no company identifying the same breed in his DNA. 

DNA My Dog identified Loki as Level 1 Belgian malinois and Level 4 Australian shepherd. Level 1, according to the company, means the majority of that dog’s DNA comes from that breed. Belgian malinois dogs are known to be high-energy working dogs, often suited for police work. 

“He’s medium to low energy,” said Yip Arnette, laughing. “He sleeps a lot.”

A couple is laughing and looking shocked at the results of their dog's DNA test results.
Jennifer Yip Arnette and husband, Daryl Arnette, say they’ve lost confidence in dog DNA tests for consumers. (Michael Cole/CBC)

Accu-metrics did not provide test results for Loki, despite submitting samples over 11 weeks prior. On the date of publishing, Accu-metrics still had not provided Loki’s results.

Wisdom Panel identified 23 breeds in Loki’s DNA, including Segugio Italiano, chihuahua and Anatolian shepherd dog. 

Embark identified Loki as 100 per cent West Asian village dog. 

“At least they’re getting the region accurate,” said Yip Arnette. “It’s disappointing…. It’s not telling us anything we didn’t know when we sent in the test.”

Karlsson says the difference in results likely amounts to which breeds and how many samples are in each company’s databases. Like human DNA companies, samples are compared to each company’s individual reference sets. If a dog has the genetic makeup of a rare breed, Karlsson says the company might not pick up on it. 

“The way the algorithm works is it’s like, well, I didn’t find a match, so I’m going to go find the next closest thing and just sort of make a guess, and that’s where it can get inaccurate,” said Karlsson.

But Karlsson says purebred dogs are easier to detect and identify.

A chart showing what breeds companies identified in Quinn's DNA.
Companies couldn’t agree whether Quinn’s DNA was purebred Great Dane. (David Abrahams/CBC)

For Quinn, Wisdom Panel and Embark both said she is 100 per cent Great Dane, but DNA My Dog said she was also Level 4 Staffordshire terrier. 

Weger didn’t buy those results, and says Quinn’s winning results at dog shows, where she competes to be the best and healthiest representation of the Great Dane breed, speak for themselves.

Accu-metrics identified Quinn as 100 per cent chihuahua, the same breed Marketplace told the company 52-kilogram Quinn was suspected of being. Chihuahuas typically weigh no more than 2.7 kilograms. 

Quinn's owners faces show shock at her DNA results.
Michelle Weger and her husband, Nabil Ould-Brahim, say they don’t trust the results that say Quinn isn’t a purebred Great Dane. (Michael Cole/CBC)

According to experts in genetics, human DNA submitted to a lab testing for dog DNA should result in an error, and not in any type of dog breed.

However, after submitting the DNA of Dhanraj, two companies identified his DNA as belonging to specific breeds.

A graphic shows the results of DNA analysis.
Despite experts confirming that human DNA ‘should not work’ when submitted to dog DNA labs, two companies identified breeds present in Dhanraj’s DNA. (David Abrahams/CBC)

DNA My Dog identified Dhanraj as Level 2 basenji and Level 2 beagle. According to the company, Level 2 could mean one of Dhanraj’s parents was purebred.

Accu-metrics identified Dhanraj’s DNA as the same breed that Marketplace told the company it “suspected” the breed was: Level 2 Central Asian shepherd dog. As well, it identified Level 2 Turkish kangal, Level 4 mastiff and Level 5 akbash.

A chart showing Dhanaj's DNA consists of multiple different dog breeds.
This family tree, provided by Accu-metrics, suggests Dhanraj is 50 per cent purebred Central Asian shepherd dog. (Accu-metrics)

“I’m going to have to have some hard discussions with my parents,” joked Dhanraj.

Karlsson was shocked at the results. 

“The fact that you’re getting breed calls back when you sent the human sample would make me very hesitant to use that company for doing dog testing.”

Results from Embark and Wisdom Panel both said testing failed on the human sample.

The companies respond

When Marketplace reached out to the companies, all of them said they stood behind their science.

In an email statement, Accu-metrics said Dhanraj’s result was likely from mixing up sample ID numbers, but that the dog results were likely due to cross-contamination during sampling or shipping. The company wrote that it “cannot jump to any conclusions prematurely” and offered to re-test newly submitted samples, and said it has a refund policy “on any flawed tests.” It also said results should be interpreted with the understanding that there is a margin for error. 

DNA My Dog said that since Marketplace‘s samples were submitted, it has more than doubled its breed database from 100 to 350 breeds, and it has “implemented a more comprehensive and robust testing platform” to eliminate human error. However, it says that its old testing methods were still “highly accurate,” those 100 breeds tested “sufficiently covered the most popular breeds in North America,” and if a sample contained DNA of a breed not covered in its database, the closest available match would be assigned to it, “which was typical of the industry.” 

The company said that assigning breeds to Dhanraj’s DNA was due to human error. On Quinn’s results, the company said the small percentage of Staffordshire bull terrier is likely remaining DNA from “even before great-great grandparents.” 

A woman crouching and petting her dog.
Burbidge says the results of dog DNA tests won’t change the way she feels about Molly. (Michael Cole/CBC)

Wisdom Panel says its science is openly available for anyone to see on its website, and while results can vary between companies, its error rates are lower than the industry standard.

Finally, Embark says Molly and Loki descended from populations that existed longer than modern dog breeds and it is proud to be the only company that specializes in village dogs. The company says if other companies report mixed-breed results, those do not reflect the dog’s actual ancestry.

While Karlsson is excited consumers are becoming interested in DNA, she warns them to take results with a grain of salt. 

“At the end of the day, the way an animal behaves or an animal’s health status is a combination of really complicated genetics, but also the environment that they grow up in. And so DNA is only really part of the story.” 

That’s how Burbidge sees it. 

“It doesn’t make any difference to me truly what breed she is…. It doesn’t change the way I feel about her,” she said of Molly. “She’s my dog and I’m just going to love her just the way she is no matter what.”



Source link

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

spot_imgspot_img

Must Read

More like this
Related